4925 N Bartlett Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

Listed by Katherine Muellenbach Compass RE WI-Northshore
Bought with Katherine Muellenbach Compass RE WI-Northshore

$720,000

$749,900

4.0%

Est.Price: ?

For more information regarding the value of a property, please contact us for a free consultation.

Est. payment -/mo

3 Beds

3 Baths

2,679 SqFt

SOLD DATE : 05/15/2026

Key Details

Sold Price $720,000

Property Type Single Family Home

Listing Status Sold

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 2,679 sqft

Price per Sqft $268

MLS Listing ID 1957530

Sold Date 05/15/26

Style Colonial

Bedrooms 3

Full Baths 3

Abv Grd Liv Area 1,979

Annual Tax Amount $9,689

Tax Year 2025

Acres 0.15

Property Description

Your oasis in the Bay! Just steps from Lake Michigan and Big Bay Park, this Whitefish Bay home delivers an incredible lifestyle paired with standout features. Inside, you'll find newly refinished hardwood floors (March 2026), a steam shower, wine cellar, sunroom, and two fireplaces - creating both comfort and character throughout. Radiant heat and central air ensure the home lives as well as it looks. Situated on a rare lot and a half, the fully fenced yard, spacious deck with a hot tub, and walk-out balcony offer the perfect setting to relax. Extensive updates include a new roof, new windows, newly insulated attic, new drain tile, and dual sump pumps. Exterior low-voltage lighting adds to the home's thoughtful design. 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths, with a partially finished basement.

Location

State WI

County Milwaukee

Zoning REZ

Rooms

Basement Full, Shower, Sump Pump, Partially Finished

Interior

Interior Features Pantry, Hot Tub, Vaulted Ceiling(s)

Heating Natural Gas, Radiant

Cooling Central Air

Flooring Wood Floors

Fireplaces Type Gas Fireplace, Natural Fireplace

Fireplace 1

Appliance Cooktop, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Disposal, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer, Freezer

Exterior

Parking Features Electric Door Opener, Paved, Parking Space

Garage Spaces 1.0

Garage Description Attached

Accessibility Stall Shower, Open Floor Plan, Full Bath on Main Level

Porch Deck

Garage 1

Exclusions seller's personal property

Building

Lot Description Fenced Yard

Entry Level 2 Story

Sewer Municipal Sewer

Water Municipal Water

Architectural Style Colonial

Level or Stories 2 Story

Structure Type Aluminum Siding

Schools

Elementary Schools Cumberland

Middle Schools Whitefish Bay

High Schools Whitefish Bay

School District Whitefish Bay

Others

Tax ID 2010455000

Read Less Info

Want to know what your home might be worth? Contact us for a FREE valuation!

Submit

Keshia Tally

keshia@ktallyre.com +1(262) 283-1639

Our team is ready to help you sell your home for the highest possible price ASAP

GET MORE INFORMATION

REVIEWS

Ruth Chojnacki

October 20, 2023

Keshia is a superb real estate agent whose extraordinary competence and responsiveness inspired our confidence during a summer of searching. She listened carefully to what we hoped to find in a new home as we assessed those we visited, pointing out good and not-so-good qualities at each.. Her availability, consistent communication, warmth, and extraordinary diligence were a wonderful source of support for us. Most important, Keshia identified a home that perfectly matched our desires and guided us to a successful offer. In short, we loved working with Keshia Tally. We are grateful for her service and sure that prospective real estate clients will find her an excellent partner.

Michael C

January 20, 2024

Keshia was part of the team that helped a mutual client of ours close. She was great to work with, super professional, even when there were some challenge with the seller's title company. Do yourself a favor and hire Keshia as a buyer or seller agent; you will not be disappointed.

Evelyn and Jay

May 1, 2025

Keshia was very thorough and professional from the first day my husband and I spoke to her on the phone! She made the process easy and was always on time. We appreciate the fact that she went above and beyond to save our deal. Thank you for keeping your word and making our dream come true.