Milwaukee Neighborhoods Compared: Where Should You Buy?
Introduction
One of the most common questions I hear from buyers is, "Where should I buy in Milwaukee?" It's a great question because choosing the right neighborhood is just as important as finding the right house. Milwaukee is a city of neighborhoods, each with its own character, advantages, and community feel.
Having sold homes across Milwaukee—from Bay View to Shorewood, from Riverwest to the North Shore suburbs—I've developed deep knowledge of what makes each area special and who they're best suited for. Let's break down Milwaukee's most popular neighborhoods for home buyers.
How to Choose the Right Milwaukee Neighborhood for You
Before we dive into specific neighborhoods, consider these factors:
Lifestyle Priorities:
- Do you want walkability or is driving fine?
- Urban energy or quiet suburban streets?
- Trendy restaurants or family parks?
Practical Considerations:
- Your commute to work
- School district quality (if you have or plan to have children)
- Access to highways and public transit
- Proximity to family and friends
Financial Factors:
- Price ranges vary dramatically by neighborhood
- Property taxes differ significantly
- Future appreciation potential
- HOA fees (in some areas)
Community Values:
- Arts and culture scene
- Diversity and inclusion
- Community events and engagement
- Safety and security
Now let's explore the neighborhoods.
The East Side & Downtown Neighborhoods
Lower East Side
- Price Range: $250,000-$500,000
- Vibe: Urban, young professional, walkable
- Highlights: Lake Michigan access, Brady Street restaurants, eclectic shops
- Schools: Milwaukee Public Schools
- Best For: Singles and couples who want city living with lake views
- Transportation: Good public transit, bikeable
Third Ward
- Price Range: $300,000-$700,000+
- Vibe: Upscale urban, arts district, modern condos
- Highlights: Public Market, galleries, restaurants, Riverwalk
- Schools: Downtown schools or nearby options
- Best For: Professionals wanting a sophisticated downtown lifestyle
- Transportation: Excellent walkability, Streetcar access
Walker's Point
- Price Range: $250,000-$450,000
- Vibe: Artsy, diverse, up-and-coming
- Highlights: National Avenue restaurants, South 2nd Street scene, close to downtown
- Schools: Bilingual schools, charter schools
- Best For: Creative professionals, LGBTQ+ community
- Transportation: Good access to downtown, bikeable
South Side Neighborhoods
Bay View
- Price Range: $200,000-$450,000
- Vibe: Hip, community-oriented, established
- Highlights: KK River shops and restaurants, South Shore Park, festivals
- Schools: Strong elementary options
- Best For: Young families, professionals, anyone wanting community feel
- Transportation: Good bus routes, very bikeable
St. Francis
- Price Range: $200,000-$400,000
- Vibe: Family-friendly, lakefront, quiet
- Highlights: Lake Michigan, parks, solid schools
- Schools: St. Francis School District (good reputation)
- Best For: Families wanting suburb feel close to city
- Transportation: Car-dependent but quick highway access
North Shore Suburbs
Shorewood
- Price Range: $300,000-$800,000
- Vibe: Progressive, walkable village, excellent schools
- Highlights: Oakland Avenue shops, Lake Michigan, Hubbard Park
- Schools: Shorewood School District (highly rated)
- Best For: Families prioritizing walkability and schools
- Transportation: Very walkable, bus rapid transit
Whitefish Bay
- Price Range: $350,000-$1,000,000+
- Vibe: Traditional suburban, family-oriented, upscale
- Highlights: Village Park, Silver Spring Drive shopping, safe streets
- Schools: Whitefish Bay Schools (top-rated)
- Best For: Families wanting top schools and traditional neighborhood
- Transportation: Car-dependent
Glendale
- Price Range: $250,000-$500,000
- Vibe: Suburban, diverse, good value
- Highlights: Bayshore shopping, Sprecher's Brewery, parks
- Schools: Glendale-River Hills School District
- Best For: Families wanting space and amenities
- Transportation: Car-dependent, good highway access
West Side & Western Suburbs
Wauwatosa
- Price Range: $250,000-$600,000
- Vibe: Village atmosphere, family-centric, trendy
- Highlights: Tosa Village shops, State Fair, excellent schools
- Schools: Wauwatosa School District (highly rated)
- Best For: Families, professionals wanting suburb with character
- Transportation: Mix of walkable and car-dependent areas
West Allis
- Price Range: $150,000-$350,000
- Vibe: Working-class roots, family neighborhoods, authentic
- Highlights: State Fair Park, affordable housing, growing restaurant scene
- Schools: West Allis-West Milwaukee Schools
- Best For: First-time buyers, families wanting value
- Transportation: Mostly car-dependent
Emerging & Investment Neighborhoods
Riverwest
- Price Range: $150,000-$300,000
- Vibe: Bohemian, artistic, diverse
- Highlights: Strong community activism, Locust Street businesses, affordable
- Schools: Milwaukee Public Schools, several charter options
- Best For: Artists, creatives, socially conscious buyers
- Appreciation Potential: Strong—neighborhood is gentrifying
Clarke Square
- Price Range: $100,000-$250,000
- Vibe: Hispanic heritage, revitalizing, affordable
- Highlights: Historic Mitchell Street, tight-knit community
- Schools: Bilingual schools, improving
- Best For: Investors, buyers wanting affordability with potential
- Appreciation Potential: High—area seeing investment
Lindsay Heights
- Price Range: $80,000-$180,000
- Vibe: Community-focused, rebuilding, affordable
- Highlights: Local ownership focus, garden initiatives
- Schools: Charter schools, community schools
- Best For: Buyers wanting to be part of revitalization
- Appreciation Potential: Long-term growth potential
Comparison Chart
| Neighborhood | Price Range | Walkability | Schools | Family-Friendly | Investment Potential |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bay View | $$-$$$ | High | Good | High | Medium-High |
| Shorewood | $$$-$$$$ | Very High | Excellent | Very High | Medium |
| Wauwatosa | $$-$$$ | Medium | Excellent | Very High | Medium |
| West Allis | $-$$ | Low | Good | High | Medium |
| Riverwest | $-$$ | Medium | Fair | Medium | High |
| Third Ward | $$$-$$$$ | Very High | Good | Low | Low |
| Walker's Point | $$-$$$ | High | Fair | Medium | High |
* $ = Under $200K | $$ = $200–350K | $$$ = $350–600K | $$$$ = $600K+
Making Your Decision
Here's my advice after helping over 100 buyers choose their Milwaukee neighborhood:
Visit Multiple Times: Come during different times of day and week. A neighborhood feels different on Saturday afternoon versus Tuesday morning.
Talk to Residents: People are usually happy to share what they love (and don't love) about their neighborhood.
Check the Commute: Drive it during rush hour. That 15-minute drive can become 35 minutes at 8am.
Walk Around: The best way to feel a neighborhood is to walk it. Check out the local coffee shop, park, and main street.
Think Long-Term: Are you buying a 5-year home or a 20-year home? That changes the equation.
Trust Your Gut: Data is important, but so is how you feel when you're there.
Conclusion
Milwaukee's diversity of neighborhoods means there's truly something for everyone, whether you're a first-time buyer with a tight budget or a move-up buyer seeking the best schools and amenities. The key is matching your lifestyle, priorities, and budget with the right community.
As someone who's sold homes across all these neighborhoods, I can provide insider perspective on which areas are right for your specific situation. I've seen how choosing the right neighborhood transforms not just your daily life but your long-term wealth building through real estate.
Ready to explore Milwaukee neighborhoods in person? Let's schedule a neighborhood tour where I'll show you areas that match your criteria and share insights you won't find online.
[Schedule a Neighborhood Tour] | [Search Homes by Neighborhood] | [Download: Milwaukee Neighborhood Comparison Guide]
Categories
Recent Posts
